Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy

Media Akuakultur recognizes the increasing use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in scientific research and scholarly publishing. This policy establishes principles for the responsible, transparent, and ethical use of AI technologies throughout the publication process.

1. General Policy

Media Akuakultur recognizes the increasing use of Artificial Intelligence (AI), including generative AI, large language models (LLMs), chatbots, and AI-assisted technologies, in scientific research and scholarly publishing.

The journal permits the responsible and transparent use of AI tools to support manuscript preparation and research activities, provided that their use does not compromise scientific integrity, research validity, originality, confidentiality, or publication ethics.

AI tools cannot replace human intellectual contributions, scientific judgment, or accountability. Authors, reviewers, and editors remain fully responsible for their respective contributions and decisions throughout the publication process.

This policy applies to all parties involved in the publication process, including authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial staff.

2. Use of AI by Authors

Authors may use AI-assisted tools for appropriate purposes, including:

  • Improving grammar, spelling, punctuation, and language quality.
  • Translating text and improving readability.
  • Improving sentence structure and manuscript organization.
  • Assisting with literature exploration and preliminary information gathering.
  • Supporting coding, statistical workflows, and data analysis, provided that the methods and outputs are independently verified.
  • Assisting in the preparation of figures and graphical materials, subject to the requirements for scientific accuracy, originality, and copyright.

However, authors must ensure that AI-generated information is accurate, verifiable, and supported by appropriate scientific references.

The following practices are strictly prohibited:

  • Using AI to fabricate, manipulate, or falsify research data, experimental results, images, or scientific evidence.
  • Generating fictitious references, citations, or bibliographic information.
  • Presenting AI-generated interpretations, hypotheses, or conclusions as independently established scientific findings without proper verification.
  • Using AI-generated text or images in a manner that constitutes plagiarism, misrepresentation, or copyright infringement.
  • Using AI to create or alter scientific images in ways that misrepresent experimental observations or research results.
  • Submitting manuscripts containing substantial AI-generated scientific content without appropriate human verification and disclosure.

Authors must not list AI tools, chatbots, or other AI-assisted technologies as authors or co-authors because these tools cannot assume responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the published work.

3. Disclosure of AI Use

Authors must disclose the use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies when these tools have contributed to the preparation or production of the submitted manuscript.

The disclosure must identify:

  1. The name of the AI tool and, where possible, its version.
  2. The purpose for which the tool was used.
  3. The specific part or activity of the manuscript preparation or research process in which AI was involved.
  4. The extent of human verification and responsibility for the generated output.

The disclosure should be included in an appropriate section of the manuscript, such as Acknowledgments or Materials and Methods, depending on the nature of its use.

Routine spelling, grammar, and punctuation correction using conventional editing tools does not require a separate declaration. However, the use of generative AI for substantive language rewriting or content generation must be disclosed.

Example of an AI Use Declaration

"The authors used [name of AI tool] for [specific purpose, e.g., language editing and improving manuscript readability]. All AI-assisted outputs were critically reviewed and verified by the authors. The authors take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the submitted manuscript."

Declaration When No AI Tools Were Used

"The authors declare that no generative AI tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript."

4. Use of AI by Reviewers

Peer reviewers must maintain the confidentiality, independence, and integrity of the peer-review process.

Reviewers are prohibited from:

  • Uploading submitted manuscripts, unpublished data, figures, tables, supplementary materials, or confidential editorial correspondence to external generative AI platforms.
  • Using generative AI to produce substantive scientific evaluations or generate peer-review reports.
  • Allowing AI tools to determine the scientific merit, originality, validity, or suitability of a manuscript for publication.
  • Sharing confidential information obtained during the review process with AI systems.

Reviewers may use appropriate non-generative tools for spelling and grammar correction of their own review comments, provided that no confidential manuscript content is disclosed.

Reviewers remain personally responsible for the accuracy, fairness, and scientific quality of their evaluations.

5. Use of AI by Editors and Editorial Staff

Editors and editorial staff must ensure that AI technologies are used responsibly and do not compromise editorial independence or confidentiality.

Editors and editorial staff are prohibited from:

  • Uploading submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, or confidential editorial communications to external generative AI platforms.
  • Using AI to independently determine editorial decisions, including acceptance, rejection, or revision recommendations.
  • Using AI-generated assessments as a substitute for their own scientific judgment and evaluation.
  • Disclosing confidential author, reviewer, or editorial information through AI platforms.

AI-assisted tools may be used for limited administrative purposes, such as general correspondence, language correction, and workflow support, provided that confidentiality is maintained.

All editorial decisions must remain under the authority and responsibility of the journal's editors.

6. AI-Generated Images, Figures, and Graphical Materials

The use of AI-generated images, illustrations, and graphical materials must be carefully evaluated to ensure scientific integrity and copyright compliance.

Authors must not use AI-generated images as substitutes for actual experimental photographs, microscopy images, histological observations, electrophoresis results, or other scientific evidence.

AI-generated graphical materials may only be considered when their use is scientifically appropriate, clearly disclosed, and does not misrepresent research findings.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that all figures and graphical materials comply with applicable copyright, licensing, and ethical requirements.

7. Detection and Investigation of Improper AI Use

Media Akuakultur reserves the right to investigate suspected inappropriate, undisclosed, or unethical use of AI in submitted or published manuscripts.

The journal may request clarification, additional documentation, original research data, or other relevant evidence from authors when necessary.

If improper AI use is identified, the journal may take appropriate actions in accordance with its publication ethics policies and established publication ethics guidelines. These actions may include:

  1. Requesting clarification or correction of the manuscript.
  2. Returning the manuscript for revision.
  3. Rejecting the manuscript.
  4. Retracting a published article when serious violations of research or publication integrity are established.

The use of AI-detection software alone will not be considered sufficient evidence of misconduct. Any suspected violation must be evaluated through editorial assessment and appropriate supporting evidence.

8. Policy Review and Updates

This policy may be reviewed and updated periodically to reflect developments in AI technologies, scholarly publishing standards, and recommendations from recognized publication ethics organizations.

Media Akuakultur is committed to promoting responsible AI use while maintaining transparency, scientific integrity, and the quality of scholarly communication.

Policy References

  1. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Authorship and AI Tools.
    https://publicationethics.org/
  2. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Recommendations: Use of Artificial Intelligence in Publishing.
    https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/artificial-intelligence/

Media Akuakultur · Artificial Intelligence Policy