Reviewer Guidelines

The Indonesian Aquaculture Journal (IAJ) relies on qualified reviewers to ensure the scientific quality, originality, relevance, and integrity of manuscripts submitted for publication. Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, timely, and confidential evaluations to assist the Editors in making editorial decisions and to help authors improve their manuscripts.

1. Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Evaluate the manuscript objectively and fairly based on its scientific merit.

  • Provide clear, constructive, and evidence-based comments.

  • Assess the originality, significance, methodological soundness, clarity, and relevance of the manuscript.

  • Identify major scientific, methodological, ethical, or presentation issues.

  • Maintain the confidentiality of the manuscript and all information related to the review process.

  • Declare any potential conflict of interest before accepting the review assignment.

  • Complete the review within the timeframe specified by the journal.

  • Avoid personal, discriminatory, or inappropriate comments about the authors.

2. Before Accepting a Review

Before accepting a review invitation, please consider whether:

  • The manuscript falls within your area of expertise.

  • You are able to complete the review within the requested timeframe.

  • You have no financial, professional, personal, institutional, or other conflict of interest with the authors or the research.

  • You can conduct the review independently and objectively.

If you are unable to review the manuscript, please decline the invitation promptly so that the Editor can invite another reviewer.

3. Confidentiality

All manuscripts submitted to the Indonesian Aquaculture Journal are confidential documents.

Reviewers must not:

  • Share the manuscript or any part of it with other individuals without prior permission from the Editor.

  • Discuss the manuscript with unauthorized persons.

  • Use unpublished data, findings, methods, or ideas contained in the manuscript for personal or professional advantage.

  • Contact the authors directly regarding the manuscript.

Any information obtained through the peer-review process must remain confidential.

4. Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must disclose any potential conflict of interest that could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, their assessment of the manuscript.

Potential conflicts may include:

  • Recent collaboration with one or more authors;

  • Employment at the same institution;

  • Personal or professional relationships;

  • Financial interests related to the research;

  • Direct academic competition; or

  • Any circumstance that may prevent an impartial assessment.

If there is uncertainty regarding a potential conflict of interest, reviewers should contact the Editor before proceeding with the review.

5. General Criteria for Manuscript Evaluation

Reviewers should consider the following aspects when evaluating a manuscript:

A. Relevance and Scope

  • Is the manuscript relevant to aquaculture science and within the Focus and Scope of the Indonesian Aquaculture Journal?

  • Does the study address an important issue or contribute meaningful knowledge to aquaculture development, management, technology, or related disciplines?

B. Originality and Scientific Contribution

  • Does the manuscript present original research, findings, approaches, or interpretations?

  • Does the study provide a meaningful contribution to existing scientific knowledge?

  • Is the novelty or significance of the research clearly demonstrated?

C. Title

  • Is the title concise, informative, and representative of the study?

  • Does it accurately reflect the main subject and findings of the manuscript?

D. Abstract

  • Does the abstract clearly summarize the background or purpose, methods, major results, and conclusions?

  • Is it concise and consistent with the main manuscript?

  • Does it adequately communicate the scientific contribution of the study?

E. Keywords

  • Are the keywords relevant and representative of the main topics of the manuscript?

  • Do they support the discoverability and indexing of the article?

F. Introduction

  • Is the research problem clearly identified?

  • Is the scientific background adequately presented?

  • Are relevant and current references used?

  • Is the research gap clearly explained?

  • Are the objectives or hypotheses of the study clearly stated?

G. Materials and Methods

Reviewers should assess whether:

  • The research design is appropriate for the stated objectives.

  • Experimental procedures are adequately described.

  • Sampling methods and sample sizes are appropriate.

  • Experimental treatments and controls are properly designed.

  • Statistical analyses are appropriate and sufficiently described.

  • Methods provide enough information for the study to be reproduced.

  • Ethical requirements and research permits have been addressed where applicable.

For studies involving aquatic animals, reviewers should also consider whether animal welfare, handling procedures, experimental conditions, and ethical approval are appropriately addressed.

H. Results

  • Are the results clearly and logically presented?

  • Are the findings supported by the data?

  • Are tables and figures appropriate, clear, and necessary?

  • Are statistical results properly reported?

  • Is unnecessary duplication between text, tables, and figures avoided?

I. Discussion

  • Are the findings interpreted appropriately?

  • Are the results compared critically with relevant previous studies?

  • Does the discussion explain the scientific or practical significance of the findings?

  • Are limitations of the study appropriately acknowledged?

  • Are interpretations supported by the data?

J. Conclusion

  • Does the conclusion directly reflect the main findings?

  • Does it address the objectives of the study?

  • Are the conclusions supported by the results?

  • Are unsupported generalizations or excessive claims avoided?

K. References

  • Are references relevant, sufficient, and up to date?

  • Are primary and reputable scientific sources appropriately used?

  • Are references cited consistently between the text and reference list?

  • Are there indications of excessive self-citation or inappropriate citation practices?

6. Tables, Figures, and Supplementary Materials

Reviewers should assess whether:

  • Tables and figures are necessary and understandable.

  • Titles, captions, legends, units, and labels are clear.

  • Figures are of adequate quality.

  • Data are not unnecessarily duplicated.

  • Supplementary materials, where provided, support the manuscript appropriately.

7. Research Ethics and Publication Integrity

Reviewers should inform the Editor if they identify or suspect:

  • Plagiarism;

  • Duplicate or redundant publication;

  • Data fabrication or falsification;

  • Image manipulation;

  • Inappropriate authorship;

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest;

  • Unethical research practices;

  • Improper citation practices; or

  • Substantial similarity with another published or submitted work.

Reviewers should provide sufficient information to the Editor to allow the concern to be assessed appropriately.

8. Writing Quality

The manuscript should be written in clear and understandable academic English.

Reviewers may comment on:

  • Clarity and organization;

  • Scientific terminology;

  • Grammar and readability;

  • Logical flow of ideas; and

  • Consistency in terminology, abbreviations, units, and scientific names.

Reviewers are not expected to perform extensive language editing, but they should indicate if substantial English-language revision is required.

9. Preparing Reviewer Comments

Reviewer comments should be divided, where possible, into:

Comments to the Author

Provide constructive comments intended to help the author improve the manuscript.

It is recommended to distinguish between:

Major Comments

Issues that substantially affect the scientific quality, validity, interpretation, methodology, or conclusions of the manuscript.

Minor Comments

Issues relating to clarity, presentation, terminology, formatting, references, tables, figures, or minor corrections.

Comments should be specific and, where possible, refer to page numbers, sections, paragraphs, tables, figures, or line numbers.

Confidential Comments to the Editor

Reviewers may provide confidential information to the Editor regarding:

  • Ethical concerns;

  • Suspected plagiarism or misconduct;

  • Potential conflicts of interest;

  • Serious methodological concerns; or

  • Other matters that should not be communicated directly to the authors.

The recommendation to the Editor should be consistent with the substance of the review comments.

10. Reviewer Recommendation

After completing the review, reviewers will be asked to provide a recommendation according to the options available in the OJS system, which may include:

  • Accept Submission – The manuscript is suitable for publication without substantive revision.

  • Revisions Required – The manuscript requires relatively minor revisions before it can be considered for publication.

  • Resubmit for Review – Substantial revision is required and the revised manuscript should undergo another round of peer review.

  • Resubmit Elsewhere – The manuscript may have scientific merit but is not sufficiently aligned with the Focus and Scope of the journal.

  • Decline Submission – The manuscript has fundamental scientific, methodological, ethical, or relevance problems that cannot reasonably be addressed through revision.

The final editorial decision remains the responsibility of the Editor.

11. Review Process in OJS 3.5

When invited to review a manuscript through the Indonesian Aquaculture Journal OJS platform, reviewers should:

  1. Log in to their OJS account.

  2. Open the assigned manuscript from the review dashboard.

  3. Review the request details and due date.

  4. Accept or decline the review invitation.

  5. Read the manuscript and any supplementary files provided.

  6. Complete the journal's review form or enter reviewer comments in the designated fields.

  7. Upload an annotated manuscript or additional review file if necessary.

  8. Select the appropriate recommendation.

  9. Review all comments carefully before submitting the review.

  10. Click Submit Review to complete the review process.

Please ensure that any uploaded review file does not contain personal information that could reveal the reviewer's identity when an anonymous peer-review process is applied.

12. Use of Artificial Intelligence Tools

Reviewers must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts. Manuscripts, unpublished data, or confidential submission materials should not be uploaded to publicly accessible generative artificial intelligence tools or other third-party systems that may store, process, or reuse submitted content.

Any use of technological tools in the review process must comply with the journal's confidentiality, research integrity, and publication ethics policies.

13. Timeliness

Timely peer review is important to authors and to the journal.

If a reviewer anticipates difficulty completing the review by the assigned deadline, the reviewer should inform the Editor as soon as possible. Reviewers should not unnecessarily delay the editorial process.

14. Ethical Standards for Reviewers

The Indonesian Aquaculture Journal expects reviewers to follow internationally recognized principles of publication ethics and responsible peer review.

Reviewers should conduct all evaluations with professionalism, integrity, confidentiality, impartiality, and respect for authors.

The purpose of peer review is not only to support editorial decision-making but also to contribute constructively to the quality, reliability, and advancement of scientific knowledge in aquaculture.