Withdrawal of Manuscript

The Indonesian Aquaculture Journal (IAJ) recognizes that, under certain circumstances, authors may need to withdraw a manuscript after submission. However, manuscript withdrawal should be requested only for valid and unavoidable reasons, as unnecessary withdrawal may disrupt the editorial and peer-review process.

1. General Policy

Authors are expected to carefully review their manuscript and obtain approval from all co-authors before submitting it to the Indonesian Aquaculture Journal.

A manuscript should not normally be withdrawn once it has entered the editorial or peer-review process unless there is a valid reason.

Valid reasons for withdrawal may include, but are not limited to:

  • Serious errors discovered in the manuscript that substantially affect the validity of the research;

  • Accidental duplicate submission;

  • Significant authorship disputes that cannot be resolved during the editorial process;

  • Ethical or legal concerns affecting the submitted research;

  • Submission of an incorrect or substantially incomplete manuscript; or

  • Other exceptional circumstances considered reasonable by the Editor-in-Chief.

Withdrawal should not be requested merely because the review process is taking longer than expected, because the authors disagree with reviewer comments, or because the authors wish to submit the manuscript to another journal while it is still under consideration by IAJ.

2. Who May Request Withdrawal

A withdrawal request must be submitted by the Corresponding Author.

The Corresponding Author is responsible for ensuring that all co-authors have been informed of and have agreed to the withdrawal request.

The Editorial Office may request written confirmation from all authors before approving the withdrawal.

3. How to Request Withdrawal

Authors who wish to withdraw a manuscript must submit a formal request to the Editorial Office through the OJS discussion system or the journal's official editorial contact.

The withdrawal request should include:

  • Manuscript title;

  • Submission ID;

  • Name of the Corresponding Author;

  • Names of all co-authors;

  • A clear explanation of the reason for withdrawal; and

  • Confirmation that all authors have agreed to withdraw the manuscript.

The manuscript is not considered withdrawn until the authors receive formal confirmation from the Editor or Editorial Office.

Authors should not submit the manuscript to another journal before receiving this confirmation.

4. Withdrawal Before Editorial Review

If a withdrawal request is received shortly after submission and before the manuscript has entered substantive editorial assessment or peer review, the Editorial Office may approve the withdrawal after verifying the request.

Authors are still required to provide an appropriate reason for withdrawal.

5. Withdrawal During Peer Review

Once a manuscript has been assigned to Editors or Reviewers, withdrawal is strongly discouraged because editorial and reviewer resources have already been committed.

Requests submitted during peer review will be evaluated by the Editor-in-Chief.

Authors must provide a clear and reasonable justification for the withdrawal.

The journal reserves the right to document repeated or inappropriate withdrawal behavior as part of its editorial records.

6. Withdrawal After Acceptance

Withdrawal of an accepted manuscript is considered a serious matter and will only be permitted under exceptional circumstances.

Authors requesting withdrawal after acceptance must provide a detailed written explanation.

The Editor-in-Chief will evaluate the request in consultation with the Editorial Board where necessary.

Withdrawal after acceptance may be refused if publication production has already substantially progressed, unless there are significant ethical, legal, or scientific reasons that justify withdrawal.

7. Withdrawal After Publication

Once an article has been formally published, it cannot be withdrawn as an unpublished manuscript.

If serious concerns arise after publication, the journal will handle the matter in accordance with its policies on:

  • Corrections;

  • Retractions;

  • Expressions of Concern; and

  • Publication Ethics.

Published articles form part of the permanent scholarly record and will not normally be removed from the journal website.

8. Duplicate Submission

Submitting the same manuscript simultaneously to more than one journal is considered a breach of publication ethics.

If the journal determines that a manuscript submitted to IAJ is simultaneously under consideration by another journal, the submission may be rejected.

The journal may also take further editorial action where appropriate.

Authors who discover that a duplicate submission has occurred accidentally should notify the Editorial Office immediately.

9. Authorship Disputes

If withdrawal is requested because of an authorship dispute, the Editorial Office may suspend processing of the manuscript until the issue has been resolved by the authors and, where appropriate, their institutions.

The journal will not normally adjudicate authorship disputes between researchers.

All authors should resolve authorship and contributor issues before manuscript submission.

10. Ethical Concerns

If a withdrawal request involves suspected research misconduct, plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, unethical research, or other serious publication ethics concerns, the journal may continue its investigation even after the manuscript has been withdrawn.

Withdrawal does not prevent the Editorial Office from taking appropriate action in accordance with accepted publication ethics practices.

11. Unauthorized Withdrawal

Authors should not attempt to withdraw a manuscript simply by deleting files, abandoning the submission, refusing to respond to editorial communication, or submitting the work elsewhere.

A manuscript remains under consideration by the Indonesian Aquaculture Journal until an official withdrawal decision has been issued by the journal.

12. Final Decision

All withdrawal requests are subject to editorial review.

The final decision regarding withdrawal rests with the Editor-in-Chief of the Indonesian Aquaculture Journal.

The journal aims to handle all withdrawal requests fairly, transparently, and in accordance with good scholarly publishing and publication ethics practices.